> < > < a b c x

Thomas Harriot

1560 – 1621  |  Pioneer of Algebraic Notation

Navigator, astronomer, and algebraist — the most accomplished English mathematician of his age, whose work remained hidden for decades.

Inequality Symbols Algebraic Notation Optics Navigation Astronomy
01 — ORIGINS

Early Life

Birth & Education

  • Born around 1560 in Oxford (some sources say Oxfordshire)
  • Entered St Mary Hall (now part of Oriel College), University of Oxford, in 1577
  • Graduated BA in 1580
  • Quickly gained a reputation as a brilliant mathematician and astronomer

Enter Sir Walter Raleigh

  • By 1583, Harriot entered the service of Sir Walter Raleigh
  • Raleigh needed a mathematical navigator for his colonial ambitions
  • Harriot taught Raleigh and his captains the mathematics of navigation: celestial observation, spherical trigonometry, cartography
  • This practical work shaped Harriot's lifelong empirical approach to mathematics and science

"He was a man of remarkably acute intellect and profound learning, especially in mathematics and natural philosophy."

— Anthony Wood, Athenae Oxonienses
02 — CAREER

Career & Key Moments

The Virginia Expedition (1585–86)

Sailed with Raleigh's expedition to Roanoke Island. Served as surveyor, cartographer, and naturalist. Published A Briefe and True Report of the New Found Land of Virginia (1588) — his only work published in his lifetime.

Patron: Henry Percy, Earl of Northumberland

After Raleigh's fall from favour, the Earl of Northumberland became Harriot's patron, providing a pension and a house at Syon Park. This gave Harriot decades of freedom to pursue research.

Telescopic Observations (1609)

Drew the first telescopic map of the Moon in July 1609 — several months before Galileo. Also observed sunspots, Jupiter's moons, and planetary phases independently.

Artis Analyticae Praxis (1631)

Published posthumously by his executors. Contains his algebraic innovations including the inequality symbols > and <. The published version was heavily edited and incomplete.

03 — CONTEXT

Historical Context

Elizabethan Mathematics

  • English mathematics lagged behind the Continent — Robert Recorde had introduced the equals sign (=) in 1557, but algebraic notation was still primitive
  • Francois Viete in France was developing symbolic algebra simultaneously
  • Navigation was driving mathematical innovation: England's sea power depended on better computation
  • The telescope was invented in 1608, opening new frontiers in astronomy

The Political Backdrop

  • Harriot's patrons were dangerous men: Raleigh was eventually executed (1618), and the Earl of Northumberland spent 16 years in the Tower of London
  • Harriot himself was briefly imprisoned in 1605 after the Gunpowder Plot (Northumberland was suspected)
  • The political instability may explain why Harriot published almost nothing — visibility was dangerous

The Culture of Secrecy

Harriot's reluctance to publish was also influenced by the culture of patronage: knowledge was a private asset, shared with your patron, not given freely to rivals.

04 — CONTRIBUTION I

Algebraic Notation & the Inequality Symbols

Harriot's greatest mathematical legacy is his transformation of algebraic notation toward its modern form.

  • Introduced > (greater than) and < (less than)
  • Used lowercase letters (a, b, c) for known quantities and (a) for unknowns, anticipating Descartes
  • Wrote products by juxtaposition: ab instead of "a in b"
  • Used repeated letters for powers: aaa for a³
  • Moved all terms to one side of equations, setting them equal to zero
Evolution of Algebraic Notation Medieval (Rhetorical) "The cube of the thing plus three things equals ten" Cossic Notation (c. 1525, Christoff Rudolff) 1Q + 3R aequatur 10 (Q = square, R = root/thing) Viete (c. 1591) A cubus + B plano 3 in A, aequatur B solido 10 Harriot (c. 1600) aaa + 3.bba = 10.bbb Almost modern! Descartes (1637) / Modern a³ + 3b²a = 10b³ Harriot's Inequality Symbols a > b a < b First used c. 1610 Published 1631
04b — DEEPER DIVE

The Notational Revolution in Detail

What Harriot Changed

  • Lowercase letters throughout: Before Harriot, different authors used mixtures of abbreviations, symbols, and words. Harriot used a consistent system of lowercase italic letters.
  • Products by juxtaposition: Writing ab to mean "a times b" seems obvious now, but it was Harriot who made this standard in English mathematics.
  • Equations set to zero: Harriot routinely wrote equations as aaa - 3bba + 2bbb = 0, moving everything to one side. This made factoring and root-finding more systematic.
  • Factored forms: He understood that a polynomial with roots p, q, r could be written as (a - p)(a - q)(a - r) = 0

Harriot vs. Descartes

Descartes' La Geometrie (1637) is usually credited with establishing modern algebraic notation. But Harriot's manuscripts (c. 1600–1621) show many of the same innovations decades earlier.

Did Descartes See Harriot's Work?

This remains one of the great questions in the history of mathematics. The Artis Analyticae Praxis was published in 1631, six years before Descartes' La Geometrie. Descartes denied knowledge of Harriot, but the similarities are striking. Most historians believe the developments were independent.

The Manuscript Problem

Harriot left over 8,000 manuscript pages at his death. Only a fraction was published in 1631, and that edition was heavily edited. The full scope of his work only became clear in the 20th and 21st centuries.

05 — CONTRIBUTION II

Optics & the Law of Refraction

Harriot independently discovered the sine law of refraction (Snell's law) by 1602 — twenty years before Willebrord Snell and forty years before Descartes published it.

  • Conducted systematic experiments measuring the refraction of light passing through glass and water
  • Recorded precise measurements of angles of incidence and refraction
  • Derived the relationship: n&sub1; sin(θ&sub1;) = n&sub2; sin(θ&sub2;)
  • Never published his results — they were found in his manuscripts centuries later

Harriot also studied the rainbow, calculating the angle at which light exits a raindrop and explaining the observed 42-degree arc.

Harriot's Law of Refraction (Snell's Law) Air (n=1.0) Glass (n=1.5) Normal θ1 θ2 n₁ sin(θ₁) = n₂ sin(θ₂)
05b — DEEPER DIVE

Harriot's Optical Experiments

Experimental Method

Harriot's approach to optics was remarkably modern:

  • Measured angles of incidence and refraction with high precision
  • Tabulated results systematically for different media (air-water, air-glass)
  • Sought a mathematical law connecting the angles
  • Found that the ratio of sines was constant for a given pair of media

His manuscript tables survive and show accuracy comparable to modern measurements.

The Rainbow Analysis

  • Harriot traced the path of light through a spherical raindrop
  • Calculated that light undergoes one internal reflection
  • Showed that the maximum deviation angle is approximately 42 degrees
  • This explains why rainbows appear at a fixed angle from the observer's shadow

A Pattern of Priority Lost

Snell discovered the same law around 1621 (the year of Harriot's death). Descartes published it in 1637. It became known as "Snell's law" or "Descartes' law" — never "Harriot's law." This epitomises the cost of not publishing.

06 — CONTRIBUTION III

Astronomy, Navigation & Binary Numbers

Telescopic Astronomy

Harriot drew the first telescopic map of the Moon on 26 July 1609, using a 6-power telescope. His sketches predate Galileo's famous drawings by several months. He also observed sunspots (from December 1610), Jupiter's satellites, and the phases of Venus.

Navigation Mathematics

Developed the theory of the Mercator projection mathematically, computing the tables of meridional parts needed for accurate chart-making. His work on rhumb lines and great-circle sailing was decades ahead of other English mathematicians.

Binary Representation

Harriot experimented with representing numbers in binary (base 2), recording examples in his manuscripts. This predates Leibniz's systematic treatment of binary numbers (1703) by nearly a century.

Atomism & Physics

Harriot was one of the first English thinkers to take atomism seriously. He analysed the packing of cannonballs (sphere packing), anticipating Kepler's conjecture, and studied ballistic trajectories.

07 — THE METHOD

How Harriot Thought

Observe & Measure

Precise empirical data

Tabulate

Systematic numerical tables

Find the Law

Seek a mathematical pattern

Record (Not Publish)

Detailed manuscripts, shared with few

The Empiricist

Harriot was fundamentally an experimenter. Whether studying refraction, mapping the Moon, or developing navigation tables, he started with careful observation and measurement, then sought mathematical regularities.

This empirical approach was remarkably ahead of its time — closer to the Royal Society's methods (founded 1660) than to the scholastic tradition.

The Silent Genius

Harriot's failure to publish is perhaps the most consequential non-publication in the history of science. Had he published his optics, algebra, and astronomy, the scientific revolution might have looked quite different.

Possible reasons: political danger, aristocratic privacy norms, perfectionism, or simple lack of interest in fame. The result: discovery after discovery credited to others.

08 — CONNECTIONS

Connections & Collaborations

Thomas Harriot Sir Walter Raleigh Patron, navigator Virginia expedition Earl of Northumberland Patron, Syon Park Kepler Correspondence on optics & atoms Galileo Parallel telescopic observations Warner, Torporley & Lower Mathematical circle & posthumous editors
09 — CONTROVERSY

The Cost of Silence

Priority Lost

  • Refraction law: Discovered by Harriot c. 1602, credited to Snell (c. 1621) and Descartes (1637)
  • Lunar mapping: Harriot mapped the Moon in July 1609, but Galileo published first in Sidereus Nuncius (March 1610)
  • Binary numbers: Explored by Harriot c. 1600s, credited to Leibniz (1703)
  • Algebraic notation: Many innovations independently replicated by Descartes, who published

Accusations of Atheism

Harriot was accused of atheism by contemporaries, a dangerous charge. His atomist views and association with Raleigh's "School of Night" (possibly an informal group of freethinkers) made him suspect.

"He did not like, or could not brook, to hear of the soul or its immortality."

— Accusation against Harriot, recorded by the Privy Council

The 8,000 Pages

At his death, Harriot left approximately 8,000 pages of manuscript notes. His executors published only the algebra (1631), and even that was bowdlerised. The bulk of his scientific work was effectively buried for centuries.

10 — LEGACY

Legacy in Modern Mathematics

Inequality Notation

The symbols > and < are used billions of times daily in mathematics, computer science, and everyday communication. They appear in every programming language, spreadsheet, and calculator.

Symbolic Algebra

Harriot's move toward modern notation — lowercase letters, juxtaposition for products, equations set to zero — helped make algebra a powerful symbolic system rather than a verbal art.

Polynomial Theory

Harriot's understanding that polynomial roots correspond to factors was a key step toward the fundamental theorem of algebra. His work on generating polynomials from their roots was visionary.

Sphere Packing

Harriot's cannonball problem — how to stack spheres most efficiently — anticipated Kepler's conjecture (1611), which was not proved until 1998 (Hales).

Computational Mathematics

His work on interpolation, finite differences, and navigation tables represents an early form of numerical analysis — computing approximate values for continuous functions.

History of Science

Harriot has become a case study in the sociology of science: how publication, patronage, and politics determine who gets credit. The Harriot manuscripts project continues to reveal new findings.

11 — APPLICATIONS

Applications in Science & Engineering

Computer Science

  • Inequality operators (>, <, >=, <=) are foundational in every programming language
  • Binary representation underpins all digital computation
  • Harriot's algebraic notation style is the ancestor of mathematical computing syntax

Optics & Photonics

  • Snell's law (Harriot's law) is fundamental to lens design, fibre optics, and optical engineering
  • Every camera, telescope, and pair of glasses applies the refraction law Harriot discovered first

Navigation & Cartography

  • Harriot's work on the Mercator projection and rhumb lines remains relevant to GPS and modern navigation
  • His meridional parts calculations were used in chart-making for centuries

Materials Science

  • The sphere packing problem Harriot initiated has applications in crystallography, coding theory, and materials science
  • Understanding optimal packing is crucial for designing new materials and understanding crystal structures
12 — TIMELINE

Life & Works

~1560 Born in Oxford 1580 BA from Oxford 1585 Virginia Expedition 1588 Briefe and True Report published ~1602 Discovers refraction law 1609 First Moon map 1621 Death 1631 Artis Analyticae (posthumous) Raleigh Period Northumberland Period — Major Research
13 — READING

Recommended Reading

Thomas Harriot: A Biography

Robyn Arianrhod (2019)
A comprehensive modern biography placing Harriot in the context of Elizabethan and Jacobean England. Accessible and thoroughly researched.

Thomas Harriot: An Elizabethan Man of Science

Robert Fox (ed.) (2000)
Collection of scholarly essays on different aspects of Harriot's work. Excellent chapters on his optics, algebra, and astronomy.

Thomas Harriot's Artis Analyticae Praxis

Muriel Seltman & Robert Goulding (eds.) (2007)
Critical edition with English translation and modern mathematical commentary. Essential for understanding his algebraic work.

A Briefe and True Report of the New Found Land of Virginia

Thomas Harriot (1588, modern edition Dover 1972)
Harriot's only publication in his lifetime. A fascinating account of the Roanoke colony and the Algonquian people.

> <

"Harriot was the most accomplished mathematician and natural philosopher that Elizabethan England produced, yet he published almost nothing. His manuscripts reveal a mind of extraordinary range and penetration, working decades ahead of his time."

— Jacqueline Stedall, A Discourse Concerning Algebra (2002)

Thomas Harriot (c. 1560–1621) — The greatest mathematician England never knew it had.